Skip to main content

"I will die for the badge" is constitutional.

This was published in TimesLive on 09 July 2025

As Provincial Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi declared at a significant career press conference that "I will die for this badge", he sounded like a military operative making a heroic statement. The plain truth, after listening to the entire speech, is that he expressed a specific aspect of section 197 of the South African Constitution, which states that "within public administration there is a public service for the Republic, which must function... and loyally execute the lawful policies of the government of the day."

The public service is a crucial part of our national public administration system, a relationship that the state organs, whether elected or appointed, must not take for granted. It is a relationship based on trust that society has placed in us to manage public power and enforce laws, including combating criminality. Upholding this trust is not just a duty, but a solemn responsibility.

 

Public trust in the public service, especially in a sensitive area like crime prevention, always hinges on a relationship with us, the people or citizens, no matter how brief. This relationship must not be purely transactional; it needs the law to safeguard its endurance. While allowing managerial or leadership discretion, the constitutional order does not tolerate unlawful prerogative or arbitrary decisions. Transparency is the key to maintaining this trust and upholding the very purpose of justice. 

 

South Africa has not fully recovered from a state capture scenario, a situation in which individuals, either directly or indirectly connected to those holding executive authority and public power, were manipulated—voluntarily or otherwise—to partake in or endorse wrongful actions. The Zondo Commission report's findings are fresh enough for us to engage with persons outside the legal system, particularly regarding state security information, especially crime intelligence. The impact of this state capture is urgent and cannot be ignored. 

 

Unless proven otherwise, General Mkhwanazi's conduct exemplifies how to respond to unlawful instructions when entrusted with a public service delivery obligation. It is fresh air on the path towards a meritocratic and capable state. Beyond his known skills and knowledge about policing, his accumulated experience further sharpens the qualities needed to address the scale of organised crime in South Africa. 

 

In his presentation, General Mkhwanazi highlighted executive overreach in matters governed by staff orders. Apart from the possibility of fudging executive authority and policing orders management, General Mkhwanazi said disbanding the political killings investigation task team was unlawful, if not a clear case of overreach. He suggested that even the police commissioner cannot order any stoppage of a criminal investigation. We have seen how the Scorpions were closed, but the investigations could not be halted; only their processing for prosecution was affected. In this case, and according to the General, it appears the overreach extended to the point of smashing and grabbing the dockets. 

 

The President and the ANC must explain why the minister should not be asked to step aside regarding reputation management and undermining the state's crime prevention efforts. This follows previous allegations at the executive level raised by the opposition, which claims a lack of fairness in addressing these issues. 

 

The decorum and forthrightness with which General Mkhwanazi conducted the press conference ticked several boxes of a trusted senior bureaucrat operating within his oath of office. He made no accusations but outlined a sequence of events, including instances of overstepping authority and accountability. He placed the onus on the Minister to prove that his behaviour in the downloaded messages was consistent with the oath of office he signed. 

 

In an organisation like the South African Police Service, where executive decisions made by appointed or elected officials can ultimately result in loss of life, trust, and betrayal hold equal significance. Any breach of confidence, particularly concerning sensitive information, diminishes morale and fosters chaos, which can ultimately turn off the entire service delivery system. Whatever the President's response to the press conference's consequences, for SAPS—especially in KZN—to remain focused, its members must trust the Minister as their leader, collaborate with colleagues nationally, and believe in themselves as operatives operating within a hostile, organised crime-infected society. This is because their leaders shape the character of a police service member; if the doubts stemming from the press conference are not promptly addressed, it could take a generation to repair the damage caused by visible wounds.

The SAPS rant by General Mkhwanazi reflects how the General in the public service often falls short of fulfilling the constitutional duty to implement the current government's lawful policies loyally. The lack of sufficient public service C-Suites and the widespread 'cadre deployment', a practice where political parties appoint their members to key positions in the public service, continues to hinder the public service from carrying out unlawful political directives. At best, individuals displaying the courage of General Mkhwanazi will be erased from the public service, and at worst, they will face relentless persecution by the system. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The DD Mabuza I know, dies a lesson to leadership succession mavericks.

When we completed our Secondary Teachers Diploma, together with two cohorts that followed us, at the Transvaal College of Education, and we later realised many other colleges, in 1986, we vowed to become force multipliers of the liberation struggle through the power of the chalk and chalkboard.   We left the college with a battle song ‘sesi bona nge sigci somoya, sesi bona nga madol’nkomo, Siyaya siyaya’. We left the college with a battle song' sesi bona nge sigci somoya, sesi bona nga madol'nkomo, Siyaya siyaya'. This song, a call to war with anyone, system, or force that sought to stop us from becoming a critical exponent and multiplier to the struggle for liberation, was a powerful symbol of our commitment. We understood the influence we were going to have on society. I was fortunate to find a teaching post in Mamelodi. Mamelodi was the bedrock of the ANC underground. At one point, it had a significantly larger number of MK operatives than several other townships. Sa...
Post a Comment
Read more

The revolution can't breathe; it is incomplete.

Only some political revolutions get to be completed. Because all revolutions end up with a settlement by elites and incumbents, they have become an outcome of historical moment-defined interests and less about the actual revolution. This settlement often involves a power-sharing agreement among the ruling elites and the incumbent government, which may not fully address the revolutionary goals. When the new power relations change, the new shape they take almost always comes with new challenges. As the quest for political power surpasses that of pursuing social and economic justice, alliances formed on the principles of a national revolution suffocate.    The ANC-led tripartite alliance's National Democratic Revolution is incomplete. The transfer of the totality of the power it sought to achieve still needs to be completed. While political power is arguably transferred, the checks and balances which the settlement has entrenched in the constitutional order have made the transfer...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Ngcaweni and Mathebula conversation. On criticism as Love and disagreeing respectfully.

Busani Ngcaweni wrote about criticism and Love as a rendition to comrades and Comrades. His rendition triggered a rejoinder amplification of its validity by introducing  a dimension of disagreeing respectfully. This is a developing conversation and could trigger other rejoinders. The decision to think about issues is an event. Thinking is a process in a continuum of idea generation. Enjoy our first grins and bites; see our teeth. Busani Ngcaweni writes,   I have realised that criticism is neither hatred, dislike, embarrassment, nor disapproval. Instead, it is an expression of Love, hope, and elevated expectation—hope that others can surpass our own limitations and expectation that humanity might achieve greater heights through others.   It is often through others that we project what we aspire to refine and overcome. When I criticise you, I do not declare my superiority but believe you can exceed my efforts and improve.   Thus, when we engage in critici...
Post a Comment
Read more